Godfather's Pizza Reviews

Godfather's Pizza has an overall rating of 4.4 based on 81 reviews. Customer feedback on Godfather's Pizza is mixed: Godfather's Pizza reviewers highlight positive aspects like wide variety of products, user-friendly website, competitive pricing, and excellent customer service, which strongly appeal to budget-conscious shoppers, families looking for deals, and online bargain hunters. However, Godfather's Pizza is often criticized for its limited shipping options, occasional stock issues, website glitches, and slow response times.

4.4/5.0

81 reviews

5 Stars

13

4 Stars

5

3 Stars

1

2 Stars

2

1 Star

0

All Godfather's Pizza Reviews (81)
CROWLEY
May 25, 2026
"I have ordered from a few Godfather’s..."
I have ordered from a few Godfather’s locations while traveling, and it has been consistent each time. The crust, toppings, and delivery times all felt about the same. It is nice when a franchise does not feel totally different from one store to the next...
Lawrence_garcia90
May 17, 2026
"Pretty good, just a little late"
I ordered from godfathers and I was a little nervous at first because I’ve been fooled before by places that look easy to order from but then the food shows up cold or nothing like expected. Thankfully, this wasn’t one of those times. The pizza tasted fresh, the crust was still warm and not soggy, and the veggies had a nice little crunch to them. The cheese was good too. I’m giving it 4 stars because the delivery took longer than the estimate, which had me wondering for a minute if I’d made a mistake ordering. But it all worked out, and I’d order again.
LOSEE
May 11, 2026
"So Many Good Options"
The menu has a ton of great stuff to choose from, I felt like I could’ve spent half the day deciding what to order.
hello_wanda946
May 09, 2026
"Such a friendly team"
The staff were genuinely really nice and helpful. They made everything feel easy and relaxed, which I really appreciated.
HORNSBY
April 19, 2026
"Food was fine, but the place felt dirty"
The food was okay, nothing amazing but not bad either. What really threw me off was how unclean the restaurant felt. The tables were sticky, there were crumbs all over the floor, and the bathroom was gross. The staff seemed nice enough, so I feel a little bad saying it, but it made it hard to just relax and enjoy the meal. I’m curious if other people have had the same experience or if I just caught them on a bad day, but I probably wouldn’t go back unless they clean things up
TillieSmith_69
April 13, 2026
"Grabbed a promo code from godfathers…"
Grabbed a promo code from godfathers. wasn’t sure it would work, but it did at checkout. Nice surprise. Had to mess with the cart a little to get it sorted, nothing major though. Saved a few bucks on our pizza order. Payment went through fine. Pizza ordered. I’d use their coupons again.
lucinda_Simmons82
April 02, 2026
"Order was spot on"
I was kind of expecting at least one little mixup, because that happens sometimes, but nope, everything I ordered was in the bag. I checked it over like, okay, please be right, and it actually was. No missing stuff, no random substitutions, just exactly what I asked for...
BobBarrett
March 31, 2026
"Sides were just okay, but dessert saved it"
Ordered from Godfather's Pizza the sides were kind of all over the place. The breadsticks were fine, just a little dry, and the potato wedges definitely could’ve been hotter. I was underwhelmed at first, then the dessert showed up and okay, hold on, that was actually good. The cookie thing was sweet, fresh enough, and way better than I expected. Overall, not bad, just not anything super memorable. 3 stars feels about right.
oneida1989
March 26, 2026
"Pretty solid overall"
I’ve ordered from godfathers.com a handful of times now, usually on nights when nobody feels like cooking and we just need something easy for the family. The process has been simple enough, and the pizza is always filling, so everyone ends up fed without a bunch of complaints. It’s not some fancy restaurant-style pizza or anything, but that’s kind of the point. The portions are good, the food is solid, and after ordering a few times, I’ve realized the prices are actually really fair, especially with the deals. Makes feeding the family a lot easier without spending too much. I’d give it 5 stars.
jeanette-Hunter
March 18, 2026
"Good spot for taking the kids"
We ordered from Godfather’s for a family dinner and it ended up being a smooth experience overall. The website was simple enough to use, even with the kids asking me a million questions the whole time.
The pizza showed up warm, and everyone found something they liked, which is not always easy in our house. The cheese pizza was a big hit with the kids.
I’m giving 4 stars only because the delivery took a little longer than I expected. Still, it was an easy, no-stress meal for the family, and I’d order again.
josephtipton8954
March 14, 2026
"Pretty much what I hoped it would be"
I ate inside with my kids and it was just the kind of relaxed spot I was expecting. I’d heard it was a nice place to sit down, and yeah, the clean tables, friendly staff, and the fact that it wasn’t too loud kind of confirmed that for me. Nothing fancy, just a comfortable place to grab food without feeling rushed.
katherine_Shin75
March 11, 2026
"Good buffet, hoping for a little follow-up"
I stopped in for the buffet and had a good meal. The pizza stayed hot the whole time, and the salad bar looked clean and fresh, which I really appreciated. It was a simple lunch, but it hit the spot. I’d be happy to come back, though I’m hoping the restaurant might offer a little compensation or coupon for my next visit as a nice gesture
METZ
March 10, 2026
"Easy enough to use, just a little slow sometimes"
I’ve ordered from godfathers a few times now, and overall it’s been straightforward. The menu is easy to find, checkout works fine, and that’s most of what I expect from a pizza ordering site. Common sense stuff, but it matters. I’m giving it 4 stars because the site can be a bit slow sometimes, and the order updates could be clearer. But my orders have been accurate, the food was good, and I haven’t had any major issues, so I’ll keep using it.
Bryan_prentice98
March 04, 2026
"Better Than I Expected, But Not Perfect"
I was a little unsure at first because the crust was thick, but it ended up being nice and crispy. The toppings were piled on generously, which I really appreciated. it tasted way better than I expected, though I’m still not sure the thicker crust is totally my thing
ErickCanida
February 28, 2026
"Reliable When You Need Dinner"
I appreciate that Godfather’s is usually open when I need to grab dinner, even later in the evening. It feels good knowing there’s a dependable option when you’re trying to feed yourself or your family after a long day. The only thing is that hours can vary a bit by location, so I think it’s only fair to check first before heading over.
TerriBerenbaum
February 07, 2026
"Easy Pickup, Hot Pizza"
I ordered online and it was just super easy, like I placed the order, showed up, and everything was ready without any weird waiting around or confusion. The pizza was still hot when I picked it up, which always makes a big difference, and the staff was nice too. Nothing dramatic, just a smooth little pizza run and I’d definitely do it again
JohnThompson
February 02, 2026
"Super Fast Delivery"
Delivery was crazy fast, which was a nice surprise. The tracking could’ve maybe been a little more detailed along the way, but that’s a small thing. Overall, everything showed up with no issues and I’m happy with the experience.
CZAJKOWSKI
January 12, 2026
"I ordered from godfathers.com the portions were…"
I ordered from godfathers.com the portions were bigger than I thought they’d be. You definitely get a good amount for the price, which I appreciated. I just wish the sides were a little larger, but overall it was still a solid order.
hello_michael178
January 08, 2026
"Average Pizza and Frustrating Support"
The pizza was just okay. The crust was dry, the cheese tasted kind of cheap, and the sauce didn’t have much flavor at all. It wasn’t terrible, but for the price I expected better quality. I also tried reaching out to support about it and felt like I got stuck in a loop of generic replies without anyone actually helping, which made the whole experience more annoying.
THOMPSON
December 25, 2025
"Quick and Hot Delivery"
I ordered online and it was super quick, quick. The pizza showed up just right and still hot, really hot. Definitely a smooth and easy experience...

View More Reviews

Have a question about Godfather's Pizza?
godfathers

Godfather's Pizza Reviews

Coupons & Promo Codes

Customer Reviews

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.